FanFiction ID: 9820196
Status: Complete (19 chapters)
My rating: 4 of 5
Danny knew something was off when his entire English class won a fancy cruise–in a contest no one remembered ever entering. Unsurprisingly, it’s not long before things go horribly pear-shaped, leaving the class stranded alone on an island, all their technology fried, and non-native tropical animals dangerously near. Worse, Danny has lost half of his ghost powers due to some weird barrier surrounding the island. Now the class is going to have to work together to survive, and Danny is going to have to be the hero his friends know him to be . . . somehow without revealing his more famous alter ego to the rest of the class.
Okay, maybe the basic premise of this story isn’t the most original ever, but I found the execution of the story in A Phantom Marooned to be quite enjoyable. The character development is well done, allowing more optimism and less angst than a lot of DP stories I’ve read. The characters are a bit older–around sixteen at this point–and they’re allowed to grow as people while still operating within their root personalities. There’s a nice blend of adventure and suspense–lots of tension both from the situation and from Danny’s trying so hard to keep his secret–with a pleasant dash of romance thrown in–both between Danny and Sam, and unexpectedly but welcomely, between Tucker and Valerie. Plus plenty of BAMFery on Danny’s part, which is thoroughly satisfying. If you want a story where he gets to shine and actually be recognized for being amazing as Danny Fenton, not just as Danny Phantom, then this is your story. I will warn that, although the author has this rated as K+, it’s probably closer to a T, maybe a T+. There isn’t a lot of language, and the romance is kept remarkably innocent and sweet, but later in the story, the group runs into a very violent, crazy group of bad guys, and . . . lets just say there’s a lot of blood and whump at certain points. The writing itself is quite good; there are a few grammatical/word choice issues at times, but nothing too obnoxious, and certainly not enough to detract from how enjoyable the story is as a whole. Definitely recommended.
Note: You can find A Phantom Marooned at https://www.fanfiction.net/s/9820196/1/A-Phantom-Marooned.
Author/Illustrator: Marcus Sedgwick
My rating: 4 of 5
Ten-year-old Zoe lives in a world that has been overwhelmed by water. She’s never known anything else, but she knows the world wasn’t always this way. . . . And she knows it’s getting worse. A while back, as food supplies became more scarce and the small island that used to be Norwich continued to shrink, her family escaped on a ship to the larger landmass to the west. But in the confusion of the departure, Zoe got left in Norwich on her own. Now she is setting forth alone in a rowboat across the floods to find her family and a safe place to live, equipped with nothing but her father’s old compass.
Floodland is the first Sedgwick that I’ve read, and it definitely made me want to read more. It’s quite short and easy to read, making it a nice, quick read–and it’s appropriate for middle-grade readers as well as young adults (and adults). The writing style is enjoyable, and the characters and observations are interesting. There’s a good balance between the action and the more psychological aspects, which makes it much more enjoyable that it would otherwise be. Probably one of the most interesting facets of the book is when it takes place. You hear plenty about “global warming” and “protecting the planet”–but it hits you in a very different way when you hear the story from the perspective of a kid who knows nothing except a planet that’s already devastated. Plus, the flooded-earth plot choice was a really nice change from the post-apocalyptic dystopian stuff you usually see when you’re talking about ruining the earth. My one complaint was that the end seemed too perfect; I don’t think most people would react in the way Zoe did. But then, her being ten makes it more likely, and it’s nice in that it gives the story a hopeful conclusion. I guess it’s appropriate, especially considering that this is for pre-teen readers as well as YA. All in all, Floodland was a though-provoking, intriguing story that I would generally recommend to most readers.
Author: Stephen King
In our world of comforts and conveniences, cars and refrigerators full of food, it’s easy to forget that there’s a big, scary world out there . . . and most of us are little equipped to deal with any of it. Nine-year-old Trisha McFarland gets a very real reminder that the world is terrifying–and full of things we don’t fully understand–when she wanders off the path during a hiking trip, trying to get avoid the argument her mother and brother are clamorously having further up the trail. What began as a quick detour rapidly deteriorates into desperate lostness–which continues for days as Trisha keeps walking, surviving on the snacks she brought for the hike and, later, on whatever she can scrounge up. Sometimes, she feels like giving up, but the example set by her hero Tom Gordon somehow keeps her looking up and pressing on. . . . But how long can she last?
I have heard a lot about Stephen King’s writing, but other than the odd short story, The Girl Who Loved Tom Gordon is the first of his writing that I’ve read. It was totally different from what I was expecting–in a very good way. When I hear the name “Stephen King,” I think horror, mostly, not a psychologically intense look at wilderness survival from the point of view of a nine year old. I’ve never read anything that could remotely compare, to be honest. The psychological study is fascinating: Trisha’s own personality (way more mature that I was at nine, but definitely credible), her family situation, her obsession with the Red Sox, and how all these factors played in to her experience being lost in the woods for days on end. Moreover, it was strange but neat how King wove in this creepy “god of the lost” being who may have been real and may have been a figment of Trisha’s fever- and hunger-demented mind–either way, definitely creepy in the extreme. The pacing of the story was slower than I expected from “horror” writer as well; I actually put the book down several times, but kept coming back to it and enjoying it each time. It’s just slow enough that I wasn’t going to stay up late to finish (except for the last couple chapters–I did stay up late for those). I would say that if you have some patience and are looking for something a bit different from anything else and a good psychological study, The Girl Who Loved Tom Gordon would be a good choice.