Tag Archives: gender roles


Author: Tamora Pierce

Protector of the Small, vol. 3

My rating: 4 of 5

Kel has surpassed numerous challenges–including lots of people not accepting a girl in the role of knight-in-training–and has finally become a squire. Or at least, she will be if any knight will take The Girl on as his squire. To her surprise and delight, Lord Raoul sees her potential and breaks his usual habits, taking her on to train. His unconventionality, gruffness, and practicality promise to make her four years as his squire both interesting and challenging. . . . Who knows, they may even be fun at times. Not that there won’t be plenty of challenges for her to face before achieving her knighthood–an ornery baby griffin, any number of stuffy individuals who challenge her capability, a huge royal progress across the country complete with parties and social expectations, boys. But of course, Kel will face them all with the clear-headed determination that has stood her in good stead so far.

I adore Tamora Pierce’s books, and Squire is an excellent example of her writing. The characters are fabulous. Kel continues to grow as a person in this book, and I love the way her character builds with every small choice she faces. I have to applaud Pierce for writing someone so vastly different from most of her other Tortallan heroines as well; Kel’s really distinct from, say, Alanna or Daine. Which actually makes it really interesting to get to see them in the same story, interacting with each other. There are plenty of other excellent character here as well, the most developed and fun to read probably being Raoul (whom I already like from Alanna’s story, but we get a different perspective on him here, which is fun). And the animal characters are just soooo good! The writing style, as always, is very comfortable and easy to read, although I am again impressed by how unconventional Pierce’s writing seems at times in the way it homes in on small jewels of events then pans out for broad, sweeping passages of time. It’s different, but it works–brilliantly, even. I do feel the need to highlight that, while the earlier books in this quartet could easily be considered children’s fiction (First Test, in particular), Squire sits solidly in the YA genre, with Kel facing some pretty big, adult stuff like death and sex–not so much kids’ stuff. So fair warning that, while still quite clean and fairly discreet, this is probably not the ideal book to give to your ten-year-old. Still, for a YA and older audience, Squire is an incredible story, especially for those who love a good fantasy.


Leave a comment

Filed under Book Review


Author: Tamora Pierce

Protector of the Small Quartet, vol. 2

My rating: 4.5 of 5

Kel has survived her first probationary year as the first female page in the Tortallan court. Now she only has three more years to make it through as an officially recognized page before she can become a squire–and those three years promise to be grueling, full of hard physical work, intense study, and opposition of her choice to remain coming from all sides it sometimes seems. Not to mention a young maid who’s come under Kel’s protection and a collection of first-years demanding her time and assistance. But Kel is nothing if not stubborn and determined.  And the truth is that she does have friends to support her, from those among the other pages to her growing collection of animal friends to her secret benefactor who keeps on sending her far-too-expensive but always practical gifts. Somehow or another, Kel is determined to stick with it and make it through these three years.

As always, in Page, Tamora Pierce delivers an incredible story full of great characters–including a strong, relatable female lead–moving plot challenges, fantastic animal characters, and a simple, flowing, enjoyable writing style. I basically just love her writing, period. Page is kind of different from some stories in that it doesn’t so much have a huge, overarching plot path–other than the passage of time over the three remaining years of Kel’s page training. Which isn’t to say there isn’t plot; there is, quite a lot in fact. It’s just set up with a more episodic feel, and also in places with the passage of time simply flowing away without much note. I know that doesn’t sound so exciting, but I actually quite enjoyed the way in which it’s written. It explores how much Kel grows up in the course of those years, discovering her own womanhood, exploring how her gender plays a part in who she is and how she lives, her changing feelings over time, her growing as a person and a leader, her developing friendships, and the growth in her character. Page is a different sort of story, but highly recommended still, perhaps even because of that very reason. Plus, you know, Tamora Pierce, always recommended, period.



Filed under Book Review


Author/Illustrator: Marjane Satrapiembroideries

My rating: 3.5 of 5


After dinner is finished and the men have gone off to nap or whatever, Marji and the other women present settle down over a samovar of tea to gossip. Naturally, in present company, the topic turns to men, sex, and the changing roles of women in Iran as the western world gains more influence on the younger generations. Each woman has her own unique story and perspective, and these nine women are more than ready to share.

Most of you know Marjane Satrapi as the author of the acclaimed PersepolisEmbroideries is a graphic novel that could really be considered a companion volume to Persepolis, being another memoir of the authors, of a sort, and using the same unique but enjoyable art style. It truly is interesting, being invited into an incredibly intimate setting to share in these women’s conversation, and the insight provided into the roles of women in Iran is truly eye-opening. But as I mentioned in the summary, a lot of the talk is about sex, so this is definitely an adult book–I’d say 18+, although most would probably rate it more like 16+. And I’d have to say that the intended audience is primarily female, although I guess some guys might find it interesting–usually probably more like embarrassing, though. I think I’d say that for adult women who enjoyed PersepolisEmbroideries might be an interesting graphic novel to try . . . but I really would limit it to basically that group of individuals.

Leave a comment

Filed under Book Review


Mangaka: Aya Kanno

Asuka Masamune has an established reputation as the manliest guy around: cool, strong, athletic, and handsome. But there’s a secret side of himself that he’s kept carefully hidden away. The truth is, he’s an “otomen”–a guy who likes cute, girly things like shoujo manga, sewing, and cooking–but due to various circumstances, his mom would kill him if she found out. When Asuka meets Juta Tachibana (a notorious ladies’ man who secretly writes shoujo manga under a female pen name) and Ryo Miyakozuka (a cute but cool girl who, despite appearances, is much better at martial arts than at traditional “girly” stuff), he begins to open up and be his true self more. It’s a lot more fun to make yummy bento for lunch, make cute handcrafts, and hang out at sweet cafés after school than to bottle all that up and spend his time training. Only, it’s becoming more and more difficult to hide this side of himself from his mom . . . . An explosion is imminent, for sure.

I really enjoyed reading Otomen. It is a classic shoujo manga of the best sort, full of cute characters, a heartwarming story, and pretty art. Honestly, it’s rather stereotypically shoujo, to the point of exercising nearly all of the traditional plot devices (including the amnesia gag!). The plot is, on the whole, sweet and rose-colored–not always realistic (let’s face it; not everyone is going to be willing to just talk about their feelings and resolve issues graciously), but romantic and endearing to read. The characters are this fantastic dichotomy of being exactly what you’d expect from a shoujo manga and yet breaking all the molds. Take Asuka, for instance: he’s your classic shoujo maiden protagonist–innocent, sweet, kind, and girly–but he’s a guy and he also truly is cool and manly and strong, somehow. The majority of the other characters strike me in a similar sense. And the romance between Asuka and Ryo! Adorably sweet, but since when does the girl play the part of Prince Charming? I think that, while Otomen is stereotypically shoujo, it also serves alongside many other great contemporary stories to challenge traditional mores and stereotypes. In a sense, this manga is about accepting and loving people just as themselves, without trying to put them in a box–I love that about it! I would definitely recommend Otomen, especially to those who love cute shoujo manga.

Note: I really enjoy the inclusion of random pages from Juta’s manga Love Chick. Too cute! If it were an actual published manga, I would so read it.

1 Comment

Filed under Book Review